The Broken Circle, part 3

The Broken Circle, part 3

Episode 57

Jennie Behm's body is found in a cornfield two miles from her house. A coroner's inquest yields no answers. Timothy and Alison visit the cornfield and discuss their final thoughts on the story. A new suspect in Jennie's death comes to light. The Broken Circle closes (for now). In the second part of the show we discuss the 90th anniversary of Nelson Rehymeyer's death in the so-called "Hex Murder" as well as Timothy's new book, Don't Look Behind You.

If you would like to help us continue to make Strange Familiars, get bonus content, t-shirts, stickers, and more rewards, you can become a patron:
Our patrons get full bonus episodes of Strange Familiars every month. To get every episode of Strange Familiars, become a patron at Patreon.

Check out the Strange Familiars ebay store:

Strange Familiars t-shirts and other designs:

Episode 57 notes and links:

Sarada is our news reader.

Articles were from: The Scranton Republican, August 4, 1925 and The Philadelphia Inquirer, August 7, 1925.

Timothy’s books:



Michael Anderson:

Contact us via email at:

Join the Strange Familiars Gathering group on facebook:

instagram: @strangefamiliars

Strange Familiars theme music by Stone Breath. You can find more at

The music in this episode is by Buell Kazee. Songs: Why Not TonightThe Blind Man, and A Short Life of Trouble.

Supernatural Abductions, Changelings, and More

Supernatural Abductions, Changelings, and More

Thanksgiving Ghosts

Thanksgiving Ghosts